Here’s how the EV rivals are and aren’t alike

Porsche, Audi, General Motors and other proven automakers are hoping to just take on Tesla with splashy new electric motor vehicles, but the initially true competitiveness from an upstart may perhaps arrive from Lucid Motors, a enterprise operate by a former main engineer on the Tesla Model S.

Lucid CEO Peter Rawlinson is following his previous boss Elon Musk’s playbook when it arrives to generation, some technologies, dealerships and support. But it is charting a distinct path on electric powered-motor vehicle charging stations, automatic driving programs and advertising.

This is how Lucid, which introduced ideas previous week to go community via a SPAC deal, and Tesla compare with each and every other:


Unlike some newer electric powered-automobile providers, Lucid designs to manufacture all of its autos in-household, like Tesla does currently.

Rawlinson believes “vertically integrating producing is the way to go,” he stated in an interview. The comments echoed remarks on a Lucid trader contact past 7 days.

“The easy fact is that production, making sure the quality of our products is suitable, is far too important, far too vital, an activity to entrust to a 3rd bash,” he informed investors. “We have to control our personal destiny.”

Lucid is building a brand name new, “greenfield” car plant in Arizona which charges billions of dollars. When Tesla commenced its individual car assembly, it took more than the NUMMI factory that was at the time residence to Typical Motors and Toyota Motor in California.


Lucid struck a deal with LG Chem to supply battery cells, the most high-priced element of any electric powered vehicle, for its standard battery packs for its Lucid Air sedan. The enterprise reported it will announce additional suppliers in the foreseeable future.

Tesla already has discounts with Panasonic, Samsung, LG and CATL for cell offer for both of those its battery packs and energy storage merchandise including the Powerwall.

Lucid has claimed it strategies to manufacture vitality storage products, both equally dwelling batteries and utility-scale units. But Lucid would not have the distraction and funds burdens of operating a photo voltaic business enterprise, like Tesla has accomplished given that buying SolarCity in the fall of 2016.

Tesla’s history with battery provide companions could prove an gain for Tesla near-expression.

Via its longstanding partnership with Panasonic, Tesla locked in undisclosed pricing conditions as well as investments from the Japanese battery maker. Together, they very own and run a large battery plant outdoors of Reno, Nevada.

Tesla makes the battery packs for its automobiles on one particular side of the factory, whilst Panasonic makes cells for them on the other facet. However, Tesla advised investors in September that it started generating its personal cells at a pilot plant in Fremont, California, as well.

Lucid expects to make extra than 500,000 automobiles for every yr by 2030. Musk, who is acknowledged for stating bold programs but missing self-imposed deadlines, has said Tesla will “most likely” generate 20 million electric powered automobiles a 12 months just before 2030.

Previous year, Tesla made 509,737 electric powered vehicles, with deliveries shy of half a million even amid a world-wide slowdown in car profits thanks to the Covid pandemic.

Price tag and battery effectiveness

Rawlinson expects the Lucid Air to be the catalyst for a lineup of long term all-electric automobiles, which includes an SUV starting up creation in early 2023 and a lot more affordable motor vehicles down the line.

To begin, Lucid strategies to sell a higher-close model of the Air, the Dream edition, for $169,000.

By comparison, Tesla sells its Product S sedan for $79,990 for the base product and $139,990 for the maximum-stop Plaid+ model, without having introducing Tesla’s $10,000 top quality application improve.

By 2022, Lucid is predicted to present a variation of the Air beginning at $77,400, which would specifically compete with numerous Tesla models. The pricing excludes federal tax credits value up to $7,500 that are readily available to Lucid customers but not Tesla consumers these days.

It is really unclear at this time just how reduced Lucid pricing could go immediately after its 1st two motor vehicles are out on the market.

Rawlinson explained the firm’s up coming prepared auto system will be the foundation for much less pricey types in the $40,000 to $45,000 vary. But he is not guaranteed the business will ever give a car for close to $25,000, which Musk stated Tesla intends to do.

“In the longer and the fuller timescale, do we actually make a $25,000 car like Tesla’s planning to do with its Model 2?” Rawlinson claimed. “My check out is, as a corporation, I imagine we’re possibly seven or eight decades absent from becoming able to ponder one thing like that. That’s a big endeavor.”

Rawlinson says Lucid has marketplace-major battery know-how for its automobiles. His principal measure is the performance of Lucid’s batteries by miles per kilowatt hour driven.

Lucid’s cars are capable of much more than 4.5 miles for every kWh whilst Tesla’s Design S Extended Array is larger than 4, Lucid says.

EV charging

Lucid has no ideas to establish and operate its have charging community like Tesla has accomplished with its Superchargers, in accordance to Rawlinson. “Do we want to have the funds burden of a fast charging network? No, we can go asset light-weight in that. Which is the place we can conserve funds,” he mentioned.

Tesla Supercharger Station

CNBC | Andrew Evers

Rather of developing its own auto charging infrastructure, Lucid has partnered with Volkswagen-owned Electrify The us, which expects to have 800 full charging station web pages with about 3,500 chargers by the close of this 12 months.

Tesla currently operates a lot more than 20,000 Superchargers globally, according to its web site.

Lucid, like Tesla, says it will supply prospects household charging gadgets.

Self-driving tech

When it arrives to creating driverless vehicle know-how, Elon Musk has famously identified as lidar, or gentle ranging and detection sensors, “a fool’s errand.” The sensors function by employing pulsed lasers to produce anything like a reside, 3D map of a vehicle’s environment that can be go through by onboard computer system techniques.

Many autonomous systems engineers believe lidar is vital for producing automobiles certainly driverless. As a substitute of lidar, Tesla’s driver-support programs and extended-awaited self-driving features count on a host of other onboard cameras and sensors together with radar. Rawlinson thinks that option is a error.

“Do we think that lidar really should be portion of the sensor suite for (autonomous autos)? Sure, we do,” Rawlinson said.

Lucid has said that the Air sedan, which was delayed from this spring to the second half of this year, will use lidar in its sensor suite for highly developed driver-assist devices. The organization expects the technological know-how to established “a new benchmark” for the industry.

Tesla sells a premium, sophisticated, automated driving system for its automobiles for $10,000 currently, with ideas to roll out a subscription selection, far too. Although it is marketed as “Whole Self Driving,” the system’s capabilities do not empower a actually driverless, fingers-free and unsupervised trip.

As a substitute, FSD permits options over and above Tesla’s common Autopilot deal. These include sensible navigation, computerized lane modifying and Good Summon. With Wise Summon a driver can phone their auto out of a parking place using their mobile telephone like a distant command.

Tesla automobiles absence a sturdy driver checking process, which can detect irrespective of whether a driver is working with their programs responsibly.

Lucid has promised to include a driver monitoring process in its cars that will make certain motorists are applying their advanced, automated driving devices as recommended, remaining attentive to the road and their environment, completely ready to manually steer at any time.

Promoting and profits

Tesla has come to be a person of the world’s very best-recognised automotive manufacturers with out the use of traditional advertising. It has instead produced hype and focus as a result of splashy gatherings, nontraditional social media engagement, Tesla online discussion boards and owners’ clubs, and almost frequent engagement by Musk himself with admirers and shareholders. Musk has cultivated a subsequent of about 50 million on Twitter, for instance.

Lucid, by contrast, ran a countrywide television marketing campaign from Dec. 25 via the conclude of January for the Air to make consciousness of the firm and car or truck. Rawlinson reported these a campaign wasn’t automatically a element of Lucid’s ideas until finally the coronavirus pandemic last year compelled the corporation to terminate various activities.

Inside of the Lucid Air display car or truck, which is envisioned to be generated starting in 2021.


“I believed, very well, dammit, we’re likely to have to because we could not get the concept out,” Rawlinson explained. “So, we had a small foray into that, and I consider that’s been rather positive. So, I really don’t rule that out just for the reason that Tesla does not do it.”

Lucid also embraces Tesla’s immediate-to-customer revenue and support styles as an alternative of offering by classic franchise dealerships.

Lucid already has six retail areas open in California and Florida. It strategies to work 20 retail areas and provider centers in North The us by the finish of this 12 months in addition to advertising its cars online. Tesla has about 160 retail spots in the U.S., in accordance to its web page.